South Korea has
long been the world’s pioneer of plastic surgery. The obsession with plastic
surgery amongst Koreans has even been noted in an article on Business Week.
Even more surprising, the news report claimed that plastic surgery has improved
and elevated South Korean tourism. This gives evidence of how the moral
quandary of plastic surgery in western countries is different from the east, in
this case South Korea. So what makes plastic surgery an unaccepted practice for
most westerners but okay for Koreans? Here’re my thoughts of this subject
matter.
In a recent
research on human behaviorism, it was found that people have a more positive
attitude to those who are more attractive. An experiment conducted in an elementary school suggested
that teachers view aggressive acts as less naughty when performed by an
attractive child. Teachers also presume children who are better looking to be
more intelligent that their less attractive peers. Another good example that
solidifies this point is how ‘attractive’ defendants received significantly
lighter sentences in courtroom cases. In fact, attractive defendants were twice
as likely to avoid going to jail as those who are unattractive. With that being
said, I believe that humans have a tendency to want to look good. Putting on
make up every single morning, combing your hair and wearing nice clothing so
that you look presentable is one form of improving your looks. On the extreme
side, it can range from getting a Botox injection to plastic surgery. Depending
on societal acceptance and geography, plastic surgery has obtained mixed
reactions all around. Can we argue that plastic surgery degrades human
self-esteem? After all, the goal here is to look better. Plastic surgery aims
to improve the self-image of a person and perhaps, better their lives with more
positive energy and opportunities.
‘200-pound
Beauty’ is a South Korean movie that entails the life of a very fat yet
talented young woman. She sings for an artist in a small box under the stage,
containing multiple computer monitors, showing her the happenings above her.
The artist lip-syncs on queue and dances on stage so as to appear that she is
the singer. The young woman does this for a living but does not get much
recognition for her talent. This story continues on with her misfortune,
regardless of how talented she is, she is unable to find love and be respected
because of the way she looks. She attempted suicide but then decided to undergo
plastic surgery as a last resort before she really kills herself. After
surgery, she became very famous and obtained recognition for her talent and
beauty. That was the premise of half the story. In this story, her life
improved dramatically after plastic surgery. Without it, she would have found
no purpose in life and would have ended her life in dismay. I have to agree
that plastic surgery can be quite useful and sometimes essential to boost a
person’s self-esteem. As artificial as it may seem, in some cases, plastic
surgery actually changes one’s life for the better. “Better Alive than Dead”.
Perhaps one day in the future, it will be socially acceptable to undergo
plastic surgery here in the US.
You seem to imply that plastic surgery is not socially acceptable in the US, and I don't really agree with that. In certain (usually affluent) parts of the country, such as parts of California, people get plastic surgery quite often. I will agree that it's not as widely accepted as it is in South Korea, however.
ReplyDeleteI think that the acceptance of plastic surgery is something that really depends on the context. There are many different types of plastic surgery and as many different reasons why people elect to have these procedures done. For example, if someone was born with a very large nose that didn't go well with their face, it's not frowned upon in most societies if that person decides to get a nose job. On the other hand, women who get Botox and face lifts done simply because they have the extra funds to do so may raise a few more eyebrows (no pun intended). Heidi Montag, for example, underwent extensive plastic surgery for no apparent reason and faced a lot of public ridicule for it. This is an extreme case, but it shows that people react differently when people have different motives for having plastic surgery.